Is Your Silver Eagle Real?
The American Silver Eagle is the world's most counterfeited bullion coin. Learn the 8-point authentication protocol that catches 99% of fakes—including the ping test that reveals what other methods miss.
Download Free AppThe Counterfeit Problem
Why Silver Eagles are a prime target—and what it costs you
⚠️ High-quality Chinese counterfeits cost $3–5 to produce and are increasingly difficult to detect visually. Many pass basic weight and size tests. The ping test remains the most accessible method for detecting these sophisticated fakes.
Official Silver Eagle Specifications
Memorize these numbers—they're your first line of defense
| Weight | 31.1 grams (1 troy ounce exactly) |
|---|---|
| Diameter | 40.6 mm |
| Thickness | 2.98 mm |
| Purity | .999 fine silver |
| Edge | Reeded (approximately 201 reeds) |
| Mint | United States Mint (Philadelphia, West Point, San Francisco) |
| First Minted | 1986 |
🔊 Authentic Silver Eagle Ping Frequencies
These frequencies are measured from thousands of verified authentic Silver Eagles using Finite Element Method analysis.
Know Your Enemy: 5 Types of Fake Silver Eagles
Each type has different tells—and different dangers
Silver-Plated Copper HIGH
The most common counterfeit. Copper core with thin silver plating. Passes visual inspection but fails weight and ping tests.
- Weight: 26-29g (should be 31.1g)
- Ping: dull, short ring
- Eventually shows copper at wear points
Silver-Plated Zinc HIGH
Similar to copper fakes but using zinc core. Even lighter than copper versions.
- Weight: 22-26g (significantly light)
- Ping: very flat, no ring
- May feel "tinny" when handled
Cast Copies MEDIUM
Made from molds of genuine coins. Details are softer and dimensions slightly off.
- Soft, mushy details under magnification
- Surface porosity and pitting
- Visible seam lines
German Silver MEDIUM
Copper-nickel-zinc alloy with ZERO actual silver. Often stamped as collectibles.
- Slight yellowish tint
- Wrong weight and dimensions
- May be slightly magnetic
Lower-Purity Silver LOWER
Real silver but .925 (sterling) or .900 instead of .999 fine. Less common.
- Correct weight possible
- Slightly different ping frequency
- May tarnish differently
The 8-Point Authentication Protocol
Follow this checklist to catch virtually all counterfeits
- Weigh the Coin (Critical)Use a precision scale with 0.01g accuracy. The coin must weigh 31.1 grams (±0.03g). Under 30g or over 32g = fake. This catches ~80% of counterfeits immediately.
- Measure DiameterUse calipers to verify 40.6mm diameter. Fakes are often 39-40mm or 41-42mm. Even 0.5mm deviation is suspicious.
- Check ThicknessShould be 2.98mm. Counterfeiters often get this wrong because they're matching weight, not dimensions. Too thick + correct weight = wrong density.
- Magnet TestPure silver is NOT magnetic. Slide a neodymium magnet across the coin at 45°. It should slide slowly due to eddy currents—not stick, not slide fast.
- Ice TestPlace an ice cube on the coin. Silver has exceptional thermal conductivity (429 W/m·K). Ice melts dramatically faster on real silver than on fakes.
- Visual InspectionExamine under 10x magnification: sharp details on Liberty's hair, crisp eagle feathers, consistent reeding, no seam lines. 2021+ coins have enhanced anti-counterfeiting features.
- The Ping Test (Decisive)Balance the coin on your fingertip and tap the edge gently. Authentic Silver Eagles produce a clear, high-pitched, bell-like ring lasting 3-5 seconds. Use Pingcoin for scientific verification.
- Edge InspectionCount the reeds—approximately 201. Check for uniformity. Fakes often have uneven or incorrect reeding. Look for seam lines that indicate a 2-piece construction.
Why the Ping Test is Essential
The one test that sophisticated fakes can't beat
The Science Behind the Sound
When you tap a coin, it vibrates at frequencies determined by its material properties—specifically, the relationship between density and elastic modulus (stiffness). Silver has a unique combination: high density (10.49 g/cm³) and a specific elastic modulus (83 GPa) that produces its distinctive bell-like ring.
Counterfeit materials—whether copper, zinc, or base metal alloys—have different density-to-stiffness ratios. Even if a counterfeiter matches the weight perfectly, they cannot replicate the sound without using actual silver. The frequencies don't lie.
💡 The Physics: Sound frequency is proportional to √(E/ρ) where E is elastic modulus and ρ is density. Silver's unique E/ρ ratio cannot be replicated by cheaper metals, regardless of how carefully they match weight and dimensions.
How to Perform the Ping Test
- Balance the coin on your fingertip (index or middle finger works best)
- Minimize contact—the coin should wobble slightly if you move your hand
- Tap the edge with another coin or a small metal rod (pen tip works)
- Listen for a clear, high-pitched ring that sustains for 3-5 seconds
- Compare against a known-good coin if possible
What to listen for:
- Authentic: Clear, bell-like ring. High pitch. Sustains 3-5 seconds. Smooth decay.
- Fake: Dull thud. Short ring (under 1 second). "Clunk" instead of "ting." Multiple tones.
Using Pingcoin for Scientific Verification
While trained ears can detect obvious fakes, the Pingcoin app provides laboratory-grade accuracy. It uses Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) analysis to measure the exact resonance frequencies of your coin and compares them against verified reference values.
For the Silver American Eagle, Pingcoin checks for the characteristic frequencies of ~5,234 Hz, ~9,156 Hz, and ~13,267 Hz. Deviations beyond acceptable tolerances indicate a counterfeit.
Which Test Catches Which Fake?
No single test is foolproof—combine them for maximum protection
| Fake Type | Weight | Dimensions | Magnet | Ice | Ping |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Silver-plated copper | ✓ Catches | ~Maybe | ✗ Passes | ✓ Catches | ✓ Catches |
| Silver-plated zinc | ✓ Catches | ~Maybe | ✗ Passes | ✓ Catches | ✓ Catches |
| Cast copies | ~Maybe | ✓ Catches | ✗ Passes | ~Depends | ✓ Catches |
| German silver | ✓ Catches | ✓ Catches | ~Maybe | ✓ Catches | ✓ Catches |
| Lower-purity silver | ✗ Passes | ✗ Passes | ✗ Passes | ✗ Passes | ✓ Catches |
🔒 Maximum Security Stack: Weight + Dimensions + Magnet Slide + Ping Test. This combination catches virtually all counterfeits. The ping test is your most powerful tool because it detects fakes that pass every other test.
Where Do Fake Silver Eagles Come From?
Red Flags When Buying
- Price below spot: If it seems too good to be true, it is. No legitimate seller loses money.
- Unknown eBay sellers: Check feedback carefully. Look for complaints about authenticity.
- Craigslist/Facebook Marketplace: High-risk venues. Always test before paying.
- "Investment coin" emails: Spam emails advertising bullion are almost always scams.
- Sealed tubes from unknown sources: Counterfeiters now fake mint tubes too.
- Estate sales without provenance: Legitimate estates can still unknowingly contain fakes.
Safer Buying Sources
- Authorized US Mint dealers: APMEX, JM Bullion, SD Bullion, Money Metals Exchange
- Local coin shops: Established shops with reputations to protect
- Direct from US Mint: Guaranteed authentic but higher premiums
- Major auction houses: Heritage, Stack's Bowers (for collectible dates)
⚠️ Always test, even from "trusted" sources. Legitimate dealers occasionally receive counterfeits unknowingly. Testing protects you AND helps clean up the supply chain.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I test Silver Eagles in capsules or holders?
For accurate ping test results, remove the coin from any capsule or holder. Plastic dampens vibrations and alters the acoustic signature. For graded coins (PCGS, NGC), you may need to rely on the grading service's authentication—or have the coin removed for independent testing.
My coin failed the ping test but looks real. What now?
A failed ping test doesn't automatically mean fake. Environmental noise, improper technique, or damaged coins can affect results. Try again: quieter room, balance on fingertip (not table), lighter tap. If it repeatedly fails, have it professionally tested (Sigma device or acid test).
Are 2021+ Silver Eagles with new design easier to fake?
The 2021 Type 2 redesign actually added anti-counterfeiting features, including enhanced micro-detailing. However, counterfeiters have adapted. The ping test works equally well on both designs since it tests material properties, not visual details.
Do toned/tarnished Silver Eagles ping differently?
Light toning doesn't significantly affect acoustic properties—the core metal remains unchanged. Heavy damage (deep scratches, dents, cleaning) can alter the sound. Compare damaged coins against known-good examples.
What's the difference between business strike and proof Silver Eagles?
Proof Silver Eagles have the same specifications (31.1g, 40.6mm, .999 silver) as business strikes. The difference is surface finish and strike quality. Both should produce identical ping test results since the material is the same.
How many fake Silver Eagles are in circulation?
Exact numbers are unknown, but industry estimates suggest millions of counterfeit Silver Eagles exist. With 50+ million genuine coins sold annually since 1986, even a small counterfeiting rate means significant fakes in the market. Testing is essential.
Protect Your Silver Eagles Today
Download Pingcoin and get instant acoustic authentication for Silver Eagles and 35+ other coins. Detect counterfeits that fool visual inspection and weight tests. Free tier includes 10 tests/month.
Download Free on Google PlayWorks offline · No account required · Detects sophisticated fakes